How to choose between two job offers
Two offers, a deadline in a few days, and a head that keeps flipping between them. One pays more. The other feels better, and you can't say exactly why. Most people end up comparing the only thing that is easy to compare — the salary — and then second-guess the choice for months.
A better approach is to rate both offers on the same short set of questions that cover what people actually care about: how it feels, who you become, the people around you, whether it is realistic, regret, growth, and money. Then let the weighted result show you which offer fits your priorities. This works just as well if one "offer" is simply staying at your current job.
Weigh my decision — 3 minutesFree · no signup · your answers stay on your phone
The 7 questions, applied to this decision
Rate each option from 1 to 5 on each question. Answer honestly, not ideally.
- How excited does this make you feel?Picture your first Monday at each place. Which one do you look forward to, and which one do you just accept?
- How much does this fit who you want to be?Which role moves you toward the career story you want to be telling in a few years?
- How would this affect the people close to you?Commute, hours, travel, on-call, relocation: how does each offer land on your partner, kids, or friends?
- How realistic is this to actually pull off?Can you realistically succeed there? Think about the manager, the ramp-up, and whether the role is clearly defined.
- How much would you regret not choosing this in 5 years?Five years from now, which offer would you be annoyed you turned down?
- How much will you grow from this?Who will you learn from, and how fast? Scope, mentorship, and the pace of the team matter more than the title.
- How does this affect your financial stability?Base, bonus, equity (valued conservatively), benefits, and cost of the commute. Stability counts too.
A worked example
Here is how one person rated “Which job offer?”. Higher weights mean the question counts more.
| Question | Weight | Corporate offer (+20% pay) | Startup offer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Excitement | 9 | 3 | 5 |
| Your identity | 9 | 3 | 4 |
| Loved ones | 8 | 4 | 3 |
| Realistic? | 7 | 5 | 3 |
| Future regret | 9 | 2 | 4 |
| Personal growth | 8 | 3 | 5 |
| Finances | 6 | 5 | 2 |
| Weighted score (1–5) | 3.45 | 3.82 |
Score = Σ(rating × weight) ÷ Σ(weights). Ratings are 1–5; weights are Weigh's defaults.
Here the startup comes out ahead, 3.82 vs 3.45, even though the corporate offer wins clearly on money and feasibility. Excitement, identity, regret, and growth carry more weight than finances by default, and this person rated the startup higher on all four. If your ratings look different — say the corporate role is also the one you are excited about — the result flips. That is the point: the answer comes from your ratings, not from the salary line.
Common traps
- Salary anchoring. The first concrete number you see tends to pull every later judgment toward it — an effect known as anchoring (Tversky & Kahneman, 1974). A higher salary can quietly become "the better job" before you have thought about anything else. Rate the other six questions first, then money.
- Ignoring the commute. Research on commuting suggests people with long commutes report lower life satisfaction and are not fully compensated for it by higher pay (Stutzer & Frey, 2008). Price it in under "people close to you" and "finances".
- Treating equity like cash. Startup equity is often worth much less than the headline figure, or nothing. Rate finances on what you are confident you'll actually receive.
- Deciding by the deadline. An exploding offer creates urgency, not information. It is usually fine to ask for a few extra days.
The coin-flip gut check
Once you have a result, try an old trick: assign each option to a side of a coin and flip it. You don't have to obey the coin. Just notice your first reaction when it lands. Relief means your gut agrees with that side; a small sinking feeling means it doesn't.
If your gut and your weighted result agree, that is a good sign. If they disagree, look at which question your gut is reacting to — you may have rated it too generously, or it may matter more to you than its default weight.
FAQ
Should I always take the job offer with the higher salary?
Not necessarily. Pay matters, but research on commuting and on how quickly people adapt to raises suggests money alone is a weak predictor of day-to-day satisfaction. Rate each offer on all seven questions and see whether the salary gap actually decides it.
How do I compare a job offer to my current job?
Treat your current job as one of the options and rate it on the same seven questions. Staying is a real choice, not a default, and it deserves the same honest scoring.
What if both job offers score almost the same?
Then both are reasonable and you are unlikely to go badly wrong. Use the coin-flip gut check below, or ask a friend to rate both offers blind and see where you disagree.
How long does this take?
About three minutes in Weigh: name the decision, enter the two offers, answer seven questions for each. Nothing is uploaded and there is no signup.
Try it on your own decision
The example above is pre-filled — change the names to your own options and answer the seven questions. It takes about three minutes, there is no signup, and nothing leaves your phone. You can also ask a friend to rate the same options blind and compare.
Weigh my decisionYour answer, not a chatbot's. Where the 7 questions come from
Related guides
- Should I quit my job or stay?Quit or stay, when you have been going back and forth for months.
- Freelance or full-time job: how to decideYour own clients and hours, or a salary and a team.
- Should I quit my job to start a business?Your idea, your savings, and a steady paycheck you'd give up.
- A better alternative to a pros and cons listWhy pros and cons lists mislead, and what to use instead.