A better alternative to a pros and cons list
The pros and cons list is the default decision tool, and it has a well-known flaw: it counts items, not importance. Six small pros can outnumber one big con. And because you write the list, it tends to say whatever you were already leaning towards.
Benjamin Franklin, who described the method in a 1772 letter to Joseph Priestley, actually did more than count: he crossed out pros and cons of roughly equal weight against each other and looked at what remained. The idea of weighing was there from the start. A simple modern version is to rate every option on the same fixed questions, each with an importance weight, and take the weighted average.
Weigh my decision — 3 minutesFree · no signup · your answers stay on your phone
The 7 questions, applied to this decision
Rate each option from 1 to 5 on each question. Answer honestly, not ideally.
- How excited does this make you feel?Replaces the vague 'it would be fun' pro with an honest rating of how you actually feel.
- How much does this fit who you want to be?The pro that never fits on a list: does this match who you want to be?
- How would this affect the people close to you?Pulls the people around you into the decision instead of leaving them as one bullet point.
- How realistic is this to actually pull off?Turns 'it might be hard' into a rating you have to commit to.
- How much would you regret not choosing this in 5 years?Asks the question lists usually skip: how will this look from five years out?
- How much will you grow from this?Captures the long-term upside that short-term cons tend to hide.
- How does this affect your financial stability?Keeps money in the picture without letting it dominate — it has the lowest default weight.
A worked example
Here is how one person rated “Take the manager promotion?”. Higher weights mean the question counts more.
| Question | Weight | Accept the manager role | Stay a senior specialist |
|---|---|---|---|
| Excitement | 9 | 2 | 4 |
| Your identity | 9 | 2 | 5 |
| Loved ones | 8 | 3 | 4 |
| Realistic? | 7 | 4 | 5 |
| Future regret | 9 | 2 | 3 |
| Personal growth | 8 | 4 | 3 |
| Finances | 6 | 4 | 3 |
| Weighted score (1–5) | 2.89 | 3.88 |
Score = Σ(rating × weight) ÷ Σ(weights). Ratings are 1–5; weights are Weigh's defaults.
A pros and cons list for the promotion would look great: more pay, a bigger title, more influence, more visibility, a new challenge — five pros against two or three cons. The weighted ratings tell a different story: staying a specialist scores 3.88 and the promotion 2.89. The promotion wins on growth and money, but this person isn't excited about managing and doesn't see themselves as a manager — and those questions carry more weight. Counting pros would have hidden that.
Common traps
- Counting instead of weighing. Ten minor pros don't outweigh one major con. Fixed weights stop the length of a list from deciding for you.
- Motivated listing. People tend to find more arguments for the option they already prefer. Rating every option on the same questions limits how much you can steer the result.
- Missing dimensions. Lists capture what comes to mind, not what matters. A fixed set of questions covers feelings, values, relationships, feasibility, regret, growth, and money every time.
- Treating the result as a verdict. Any weighted score is a summary of your own answers. If it surprises you, that is useful information too — see the gut check below.
The coin-flip gut check
Once you have a result, try an old trick: assign each option to a side of a coin and flip it. You don't have to obey the coin. Just notice your first reaction when it lands. Relief means your gut agrees with that side; a small sinking feeling means it doesn't.
If your gut and your weighted result agree, that is a good sign. If they disagree, look at which question your gut is reacting to — you may have rated it too generously, or it may matter more to you than its default weight.
FAQ
What is wrong with a pros and cons list?
It counts items instead of weighing them, it depends on what you happen to think of, and it is easy to tilt towards the answer you already want. It is fine for small decisions, weaker for hard ones.
What is a weighted decision matrix?
A table where each option is rated on the same criteria and each criterion has an importance weight. The weighted average gives each option a single score. Weigh is a pre-built, mobile version of this with seven fixed questions.
Where do the seven questions come from?
They are inspired by Schwartz's theory of basic human values, multi-attribute utility theory, and regret minimisation. The importance weights are Weigh's own defaults, not values taken from a study.
Can I still write pros and cons?
Sure. Many people find it helps to brainstorm a list first, then use the seven questions to weigh what they wrote.
Try it on your own decision
The example above is pre-filled — change the names to your own options and answer the seven questions. It takes about three minutes, there is no signup, and nothing leaves your phone. You can also ask a friend to rate the same options blind and compare.
Weigh my decisionYour answer, not a chatbot's. Where the 7 questions come from
Related guides
- How to make a hard decisionThe general method, plus guides for specific decisions.
- How to choose between two job offersTwo offers on the table and a deadline coming up.
- How to choose between two apartmentsTwo flats, a deadline, and size vs location.
- Should I buy or rent a home?Buying a home vs renting, beyond the mortgage calculator.